The Islamabad High Court (IHC) recently granted bail to an individual accused of being involved in a massive Rs. 3.2 billion tax fraud case. The decision came with a significant warning to the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) about adhering to the law and avoiding abuse of power. The accused was released on bail against a nominal surety bond of Rs. 100.
In its ruling, the IHC emphasized the importance of following legal precedents, specifically referencing the Lahore High Court’s judgment in the Taj International (Pvt.) LTD case. The court highlighted that any actions taken by the FBR or its officials that violate the principles established in this case could lead to serious consequences, including charges of abuse of power.
The petitioner, who served as a branch manager at First Women Bank in Karachi, was arrested on allegations of aiding a taxpayer company, Kineses Energy and Power Innovations (Pvt.) Limited, in committing the fraud. The FBR accused the taxpayer of evading Rs. 3.2 billion in sales tax. The petitioner was charged with assisting the company by facilitating the opening of its accounts in his branch.
According to the IHC, the arrest and detention of the petitioner were conducted in violation of the law established by the Taj International (Pvt.) LTD case, which has been upheld by the Supreme Court. This disregard for the legal framework undermined the petitioner’s constitutional rights to liberty, dignity, equality, and due process, guaranteed under Articles 9, 14, 25, and 10A of the Constitution.
The IHC further criticized the actions of the tax officials and the judiciary involved in the case. It noted that the officials misused their powers under the Sales Tax Act in their eagerness to maximize tax collection. This overreach not only breached the law but also disregarded the petitioner’s fundamental rights. The court admonished the lower courts for failing to uphold these rights, stating that the magistrate who granted remand and the court that initially denied bail acted without proper consideration of the law.
The court directed the Chairman of the FBR to circulate its judgment along with the Lahore High Court’s ruling in Taj International (Pvt.) LTD to all relevant tax officials. This step aims to ensure that the powers delegated to these officials are exercised responsibly and within the boundaries of the law.
This judgment serves as a critical reminder for public officials that their authority is a trust to be exercised in accordance with the law. The IHC underscored that any misuse of this authority could expose the officials to legal repercussions.
The case has brought attention to the delicate balance between enforcing tax laws and protecting the rights of individuals. It also highlights the judiciary’s role as a guardian of fundamental rights, ensuring that enforcement actions are conducted lawfully and justly.
As this case unfolds, it is expected to set a precedent for similar cases, reinforcing the need for accountability and adherence to the legal framework in matters of tax enforcement.
Read Also:
